Collapse
We try to keep our shipping prices as low as possible!
Download the Blackwell's App on iOS or Android, LOG IN and AUTOMATICALLY get $10 OFF your first order!
Over 11 thousand trusted and verified reviews.
Shop carefree!
Shop thousands of brands
Free door to door delivery
No hidden costs of shipping fees
PRODUCT DESCRIPTION
Elijah Craig Toasted Rye is a rich, character-driven rye whiskey that takes the classic rye spice profile and artfully layers on toasted oak complexity. It isn’t just about heat or force; the finishing in custom toasted new oak barrels gives sweetness, chocolate, and toffee notes that balance the rye’s boldness. It’s versatile — works well neat or in cocktails — and is a strong option for those looking to explore rye with a twist.
Distillery: Heaven Hill, under the Elijah Craig label. Crafted using their Straight Rye Whiskey.
Mash Bill: 51% rye, 35% corn, 14% malted barley.
Proof / ABV: 94 proof (≈ 47% ABV).
Finishing process: After full maturation, the whiskey is finished in a second, custom-toasted new oak barrel. These finishing barrels are toasted (not just charred) in a special process developed with Independent Stave Company. The toasting includes a phase where a cap is placed on the barrel to ramp up heat quickly, embedding additional phenols in the wood surface to impart more smoke and flavor.
Age Statement: NAS (no age statement) for this expression.
| Element | Notes |
|---|---|
| Colour / Appearance | Burnished copper. |
| Nose / Aroma | Toasted oak, crème brûlée, almonds, hazelnuts; vanilla cream; lighter rye grain; hints of baking spice (cinnamon, nutmeg) and sweet fruit punch. |
| Palate / Taste | Soft, creamy mouth-feel. Milk chocolate, vanilla, baking spices; toasted oak; a touch of heat from rye pepper; brown sugar; occasional fruit notes (summer fruits, cherries, apricot) behind the oak and spice. |
| Finish | Warming and moderately long. Spices linger—black pepper, cinnamon, white peppercorn; oak takes a more central role; sweet vanilla, toffee; subtle leather and oak tannins; the toasted barrel flavor persists without overwhelming. |
Cocktails
Classic rye cocktails will work well: Old Fashioned, Manhattan, Sazerac — the toasted oak and spice add extra layers of flavor.
Rye & ginger or rye & soda, with a twist of citrus, help bring out the vanilla and honey notes.
Dessert cocktails: use in variants of whiskey-based dessert sips (think chocolate or coffee liqueur in the mix).
Food Pairings
Chocolate & Sweets: Milk or dark chocolate; crème brûlée; vanilla caramel desserts. These echo the cream, vanilla, and toffee flavor profile.
Nuts & Dried Fruit: Roasted almonds, hazelnuts; dried apricots or cherries — pairs very well.
Savory Dishes: Charcuterie – especially smoked meats or ham; roasted pork; dishes with warm spices; barbecue with a sweet glaze; anything where smoked oak and sweetness can complement the savory.
Cheese: Strong cheeses, aged cheddar, gouda, or creamy blue cheeses—to stand up to the rye and oak spice.
After Dinner / Sipping: Neat or with a large ice cube to slow down the sip; lends itself to contemplative sipping after a meal.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Name | Elijah Craig Toasted Rye Whiskey |
| Type | Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey with toasted barrel finishing |
| Mash Bill | 51% rye / 35% corn / 14% malted barley |
| Proof / ABV | 94 proof (~47% ABV) |
| Age Statement | NAS |
| Finish / Barrel Treatment | Finished post-maturation in custom-toasted new oak barrels with a high-heat cap to embed phenols & impart smoke, oak, toast character |
| Style / Character | Spicy rye backbone softened by toasted oak sweetness: vanilla, chocolate, nuts, baking spices; warm, creamy, approachable but with depth |
Bottle Size: All bottles are 750ML/700ML unless otherwise noted.
21 and Over: Adult Signature Required
Don’t worry! We won’t share or sell your email address
WHILE STOCK LASTS!
Get 1 Free Bottle of Bourbon From Bean & Sheldon

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.